Skip to content

grilling: questions are often written as statements instead of actual questions #1249

Description

@NathanAB

Problem

Grilling rounds often don't ask anything and instead posits some vague statement with the ➡️ line just saying "Yes".

This may come from the line #1193 added under the round format (fixing #706):

Word each question so "yes" accepts your recommended answer.

Example

A real round (Claude Code, Opus 5.5 xhigh):

❓ Q2 - Mods only: "Every mod" means every published mod. Status line configs get no Desktop preview, since Desktop doesn't draw status lines without a mod like statusline-anywhere.
➡️ Yes: mods only.

❓ Q3 - Mods that draw nothing in Desktop: Some mods only draw in the terminal (Raster/Image) or only run hooks. Options:
* (a) Show a plain note on the mod page: "Draws nothing in Claude Desktop."
* (b) Hide the Desktop slot entirely.
* (c) Show the empty Desktop window.
➡️ Yes to (a). It tells a Desktop user something real before they install.

❓ Q4 - Mod page only: Desktop previews appear only on the mod page, not on gallery cards or OG (Open Graph) share images.
➡️ Yes: mod page only, per YAGNI (build only what's needed). Cards and OG images can come later if wanted.

❓ Q5 - Glossary: "surface": [...] I'd add to `GLOSSARY.md`: [...]
➡️ Yes: adopt "surface" and update Preview.

❓ Q6 - Part of render:mods: The same bun run render:mods run records both surfaces, one Desktop preview per mod against clean-main. If the Desktop recording fails, the mod keeps its old Desktop preview and its terminal preview is unaffected.
➡️ Yes.

❓ Q7 - Re-pin gap stays out of scope: render:mods renders only a mod’s current version, and publish-mod refuses a version that hasn’t rendered. So a new mod version can never go live today. That gap exists for terminal previews too.
➡️ Yes: out of scope here. I’ll propose it as a separate follow-up once we’re done.

Q2, Q4 and Q5 contain no question. Q3 lists options but still answers "Yes to (a)", though it was never a yes/no question.

Related

Activity

  1. changed the title [-]grilling: questions come out as statements for the user to agree with[/-] [+]grilling: questions are often written as statements instead of actual questions[/+] on Oct 10, 2026
  2. Codeepritam commented on Oct 10, 2026

    @Codeepritam

    I can work on this. The fix seems to be making the round format explicitly distinguish yes/no questions from multiple choice questions, while preserving the existing rule that “yes” accepts the recommendation. I’ll check the current skill and documentation, make the smallest focused change, and keep both in sync. Let me know if anyone is already working on it.

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    needs-triageMaintainer needs to evaluate

    Projects

    No projects

      Milestone

      No milestone

      Relationships

      None yet

      Development

      No branches or pull requests

      Issue actions